A poor abstract can then lose the reader's interest and undo the benefit of an effective title - whilst the paper's abstract may appear in search results, the potential reader may go no further. Other journals are publishing the similar research. Such issues include: If you find a major problem, note your reasoning and clear supporting evidence (including citations). on 29 Oct, 2015, Once a paper is submitted to a journal, it is assigned to a handling editor who conducts an initial screening of the paper to see if it meets the basic requirements of the journal. wiley manuscript status under considerationmappa concettuale inquinamento del suolo MANHALNET COMPANY . Ebrahim Mostafavi, PhD - Postdoctoral Research Fellow - LinkedIn Where manuscripts have serious flaws you should not spend any time polishing the review you've drafted or give detailed advice on presentation. It also means that according to the judgement of the Editor or Associate Editor or Assistant Editor, the manuscript qualifies to be sent for review. Why the manuscript submission status changed from 'Under review' to In the previous rounds, an email was received once the status went blank. All authors have approved the final version of the manuscript and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work. "manuscript under editorial consideration" naturelettre pour quitter l'ecole plus totlettre pour quitter l'ecole plus tot Wiley under consideration. Editorial policies - Preprint Sharing | Springer | Springer In this case, you may wish to familiarize yourself with examples of other reviews done for the journal, which the editor should be able to provide or, as you gain experience, rely on your own evolving style. Page xi . Toggle navigation. B.E. Examples of possibly major flaws include: If experimental design features prominently in the paper, first check that the methodology is sound - if not, this is likely to be a major flaw. If the initial reviews are conflicting, IET Renewable Power Generation: Vol 17, No 4 A call to prioritise prevention: Action is needed to reduce the risk of What does it add to the subject area compared with other published material? If the paper includes tables or figures, what do they add to the paper? Both are very repetitive indexing agencies. 1 ADRD gradually diminishes the quality of life of the affected older population.